How a purchase gets its category
Every merchant that accepts cards carries a four-digit merchant category code, or MCC. The merchant's payment processor assigns it when the merchant starts taking cards, from lists the card networks maintain. Your issuer does not set it. What the issuer does decide is which codes earn a bonus. So the category that usually counts is the code the merchant carries, not the brand on the sign or what is in your basket.
That is why the same kind of purchase can earn different amounts. Common surprises:
- Superstores and warehouse clubs. Many issuers leave them out of supermarket bonuses even though they sell groceries. American Express, for example, publishes terms for its supermarket bonus that exclude superstores, convenience stores and warehouse clubs. The Amex Gold Card page shows how the catalogue records that bonus.
- A shop inside a shop. A restaurant inside a department store can carry the department store's code, and a restaurant inside a hotel can code as lodging.
- A middleman. A payment processor, wallet or marketplace between you and the merchant can change the code.
- Apps and subscriptions. A delivery app may code as a restaurant or as an online ordering platform. A streaming service may code as digital goods.
- Definitions vary. Some issuers count tolls, taxis or trains as travel and others do not.
The practical habit is to read your card's category definitions, then check that the first purchase in a new category actually earned the bonus. If it did not, the code is the usual reason.
Caps and rotating categories
A bonus rate usually applies only up to a ceiling, per year or per quarter, and then drops to the base rate. The supermarket rates on Blue Cash Preferred and Amex Gold both have yearly caps, and the card pages list the current figures.
Rotating categories add two more rules. On Chase Freedom Flex, you activate the quarter's categories, the bonus covers up to $1,500 of combined purchases per quarter as of October 2026, and the merchant must submit the charge by the last day of the quarter. Chase sets the activation deadline at the 14th of the quarter's third month, and explains the activation window on its own site.
Portal bookings versus booking direct
Some cards pay their top travel rate only when you book through the issuer's own travel site. Chase Sapphire Preferred is one such structure in the catalogue: a high rate through the portal, a lower one when you book directly with the airline or hotel. Freedom Flex pays its travel bonus the same way, through Chase Travel.
Weigh four things before using a portal:
- Price. Compare the same itinerary on the portal and direct.
- The extra points. On a $1,000 hotel stay, a 5x portal rate against a 2x direct rate is 3,000 extra points. That is about $30 at one cent each, or about $51 at 1.7 cents. A portal price $30 higher cancels the first.
- When plans change. A portal is a third party, so a change or cancellation may go through the portal rather than the airline or hotel, and its rules can differ from booking direct.
- Loyalty perks. Elite credit and member benefits can depend on where you book. Check before you assume they carry over.
Co-brand bonuses apply only at the brand
An airline or hotel card's headline rate normally applies to that company and nowhere else. The United Explorer Card page shows a higher rate on United flights and a lower one elsewhere. Away from the brand, the question is whether the base rate, at the value you place on those miles, beats your everyday card.
Some co-brand perks, such as free checked bags, also depend on paying with the card. The terms say which.
Paying abroad
Many cards charge a foreign transaction fee, commonly 2.5 to 3 percent, made up of a network charge of roughly 1 percent plus the issuer's share. Some cards charge none. Chase's page for Freedom Flex, for instance, states that it has no foreign transaction fees.
The fee can erase the reward. Pay a 100 euro dinner on a 2% card with a 3% fee and you finish about 1 euro behind. A card with no fee and a 1% rate finishes about 1 euro ahead. If a terminal offers to charge you in your home currency, decline: the merchant's payment provider sets that rate, and it is usually worse. The guide to using cards abroad goes through this in more detail.
Protections as a reason to choose a card
Some cards carry rental-car damage cover, trip delay cover, purchase protection or extended warranty. Rental cover is either primary, paying first without a claim on your own insurer, or secondary, paying what your own policy does not, such as a deductible. In the United States most card cover is secondary. Typical conditions are paying for the rental with the card and declining the rental company's own damage waiver, with limits by vehicle, length and country.
That can matter more than the earn rate. A one-point-per-dollar difference on a $300 rental is about $3 at a cent a point. A deductible of $1,000 on your own policy is far larger. The issuer's benefits guide is the authority on what applies, and the card protections guide covers how to read it.
A wallet rule of thumb
- Pick a default. One card with a flat rate you know, used for everything that has no better home.
- Add a card for a category only if the numbers clear your own bar. The test is the rate gap times your yearly spend in that category. A 3-point gap on $2,400 of dining a year is 7,200 points, about $72 at a cent each. Decide your minimum, such as $50 a year, and stick to it.
- Use co-brand cards at their brand, and elsewhere only if the base rate holds up.
- For car hire and trip bookings, use the card whose cover applies, and check its conditions.
- Abroad, prefer a card with no foreign fee if you hold one.
- Write the plan down and revisit it once a year, or when a card changes its terms.
How Which Card decides
The Which Card tab in ValueStack answers one question: you are about to pay for something, so which of the cards you hold should you reach for? It is arithmetic over public figures and your own wallet, not advice. For each of your cards and each part of the purchase, it adds up:
- Earn. The rate times the amount times the card's point value, with the bonus cap applied to this purchase.
- Open credits. Only as much as the purchase can use. A $300 hotel credit against a $120 stay counts as $120.
- Vouchers and spend goals. A free night you hold, or a goal this purchase would complete.
- Protections. Published cover counts for a small share of the amount. These weights rank cards and are not payouts.
- Costs. A foreign fee of about 3 percent where a card charges one. For rent in the US, an assumed processing fee of about 2.75 percent unless the catalogue says the card waives it. Brazilian cards also pay the 3.5 percent IOF tax on foreign purchases, except the few that absorb it.
Benefits tied to a place count only when they apply. An airline card's rate counts once you say you are flying that airline, and a portal rate counts once you say you are booking through the portal. Until then they appear as hints and score nothing. Ties go to the credit that resets soonest, then to the longer time to pay when your statement dates are set.
When the data does not support an answer, the app says so. Two cards that come out identical show as too close to call, and cards with no rates in the catalogue show as no answer yet. It mentions a card you do not hold only when nothing in your wallet has a bonus, credit or voucher for the purchase and that card would clearly do more, such as at least double the earn or rental cover where yours has none. Tracking your cards in ValueStack shows how to set up the wallet it reads from.
Rates, caps and terms change. Treat every figure here as an example and confirm the current terms with your issuer. This is a personal tracking guide, not financial advice.

General information for personal tracking, not financial advice. Card terms change often; check the issuer’s current terms.