Basics guide

Points, miles and cashback: what they are worth

A point is not a unit of money. It is a claim on whatever the programme will sell you for it, and that depends on how you redeem, which programme you are in and what the programme decides to change next year. Cashback is the opposite: a dollar is a dollar. This guide explains the difference and shows how to compare the two with plain arithmetic.

7 min read · 8 sections · Updated

Four kinds of reward

Most rewards fall into one of four groups. The group matters more than the headline earn rate, because it decides how much of that headline you can actually keep.

Cashback
Paid as a statement credit, a deposit or a check at a fixed rate. The value is exact and you can spend it anywhere.
Fixed-value points
Points that redeem at a set rate for a particular use, such as one cent each against a statement credit. The value is predictable, though it can differ between types of redemption.
Transferable points
Points you can move to airline and hotel programmes, such as Chase Ultimate Rewards, American Express Membership Rewards, Citi ThankYou, Capital One miles and Bilt Rewards. Their value depends on where you send them.
Airline and hotel currencies
Miles and points earned inside one company's programme. They are usually worth the most when spent with that company, and the company sets the price.

To see each type in the catalogue, these pages are examples of the structure rather than suggestions:

What a point is worth in cents

The working formula is simple: cents per point equals the cash price you avoid, minus any fees you still pay, divided by the points you spend, times 100. Everything else is argument about which cash price counts.

Points-focused websites publish their own estimates, and they disagree with each other. The table shows the range from two widely read sites in October 2026. These are editorial estimates, not figures from card issuers, and both sites say they depend on redemption choices.

TypeExamplePublished estimate, cents per point (October 2026)
Transferable bank pointsChase, Amex, Citi, Capital One, Bilt1.7 to 2.2
Airline milesDelta SkyMiles1.1 to 1.2
Airline milesUnited MileagePlus1.2 to 1.3
Airline milesAmerican AAdvantage1.45 to 1.5
Hotel pointsWorld of Hyatt1.4 to 1.65
Hotel pointsMarriott Bonvoy0.7 to 0.75
Hotel pointsHilton Honors0.4 to 0.5

Two things stand out. Hotel programmes differ by three to four times between the lowest and highest estimates, so "a hotel point" is not one thing. And the transferable currencies sit above most single-company currencies, but only for someone who actually uses the transfer partners.

ValueStack's catalogue uses its own point values, not copied from any website, and counts cashback exactly. Chase and Citi points count at the cash rate unless you also hold a card that unlocks transfers. All of these are assumptions rather than facts, and the app says so wherever it relies on them.

Why redemption decides the value

The same points can be worth very different amounts depending on what you spend them on. Redeeming for cash or a statement credit at a flat rate sets a floor, but the rate is not always one cent: as of October 2026, published guides put American Express Membership Rewards statement credits at about 0.6 cents per point. Flights and hotels can pay more, or less, depending on how the programme prices that particular booking.

A rule that keeps you honest: count only what you would have bought anyway. A premium-cabin seat that would cost $2,000 in cash looks like a very high rate per point, but if you would never have paid $2,000, the saving is imaginary. Compare against the fare you would really have booked.

Transfer partners: read the fine print first

The high end of the table assumes you move points to an airline or hotel partner. That step has traps.

  • Transfers are usually one-way. Once points leave the bank programme for a partner, you generally cannot send them back. Confirm that the seats or nights are available before you transfer.
  • Ratios and timing differ. Many partners are one-to-one, but not all, and some transfers arrive instantly while others take days.
  • Some cards cannot transfer on their own. A few cards earn a transferable currency but can move it to few or none of the partners unless you also hold a particular premium card in the same programme. Check this before you value your points at the high end. Otherwise the realistic value is the cash redemption rate.
  • Keep points flexible. Holding transferable points until you have a specific booking leaves your options open. Moving them early commits you to one programme's prices.

Devaluations and why earned points are not guaranteed

A programme can change what points buy without changing what you earned. A few documented examples:

  • Marriott Bonvoy retired its fixed award chart for dynamic pricing in March 2022.
  • On 25 March 2025, World of Hyatt moved 151 hotels to different award categories. 118 moved up a category and 33 moved down.
  • Delta dropped its published award chart for its own flights in 2015, and United did the same in November 2019. Award prices on those flights now follow demand.

One of the sites quoted above rates devaluation risk as much higher for a single airline or hotel currency than for transferable points. One reason is that transferable points can move to a different partner. Points held for a trip with no date carry that risk the whole time, so avoid stockpiling them. Cashback you have already earned is a dollar balance, so a cut normally applies only to future spending. Check the terms for what happens to an unredeemed balance if you close the account.

Cashback: simple, and simple is a feature

Cashback needs no award searches, no transfer decisions and no estimate of what a point is worth. You can compare two cashback cards in your head. The ceiling is lower than a well-used points programme, but the floor is higher, and the gap between the two is the effort you put in.

Rewards only count if you pay your statement in full. Federal Reserve data put the average interest rate on US card accounts that were charged interest at about 22.4 percent a year in August 2026. Reward rates of a few percent do not come close to covering that.

Comparing a 2x points card with a 2% cashback card

This is the comparison most people actually face. Both cards look like "2" on the front. Only one of them has a fee and a redemption step.

The fee is not purely a cost, since credits and benefits on the card may offset it. The annual fee guide covers that side of the sum. The first year often looks different because of welcome offers, which the first-year fees guide explains.

Questions to ask before you choose a unit

  • How many trips a year do you actually take, and would you book them with points?
  • What did your last redemption work out to, in cents per point?
  • If you hold a card that earns a transferable currency, can it transfer, or only redeem for cash?
  • What break-even rate would cover the fee on the card you are weighing?
  • Would you rather spend a few minutes a year on rewards, or a few hours?

The answers also shape which card suits which purchase, which the guide to choosing a card for each purchase works through. And if hotel stays are where your points go, the guide to free nights and companion vouchers shows how to value a certificate against a points price.

Examples use US dollars, but the arithmetic is identical in any currency. The United Kingdom page and the other country pages list each market's cards. Estimates here are for personal tracking and are not financial advice. Check your issuer's current terms before you rely on any rate.

General information for personal tracking, not financial advice. Card terms change often; check the issuer’s current terms.

Keep track of it in ValueStack

ValueStack is a personal tracker for credits, benefits and annual-fee value. It shows when each credit resets and how much of each fee you have earned back, and your data stays on your device.

Get ValueStack on the App StoreiPhone and iPad. No account, nothing collected.