This guide explains why the numbers start out wrong, how to find what you really used, and how to get a year-to-date figure you can trust. It also covers cards that reset on your anniversary instead of in January, because that changes what “this year” means.
Why your numbers look wrong at first
Fee recovery is a running total. ValueStack compares what a card has given back this calendar year, meaning every credit you have marked used, with the card’s annual fee, which it counts in full from the start of the year. Credits accrue month by month. The fee does not.
So a card added in October reads as far behind, even if you used its credits faithfully all year without telling the app. The Overview shows “Still to break even” with the whole fee on it, the “Fees earned back” bar sits empty, and the pace marker, labelled “today”, sits about four-fifths of the way along the year with nothing behind it.
Step 1: catch up when you add the card
ValueStack offers this at the moment you need it. When you add a card partway through the year, and nothing is ticked on it yet, a sheet titled “Catch up on this year” opens. It says what month it is and asks you to tick the earlier periods you already used, so the break-even starts from where you really are.
- Each credit gets its own block, with its closed periods for this year laid out as cells: months such as Jan and Feb for a monthly credit, ranges such as Jan–Mar for a quarterly one.
- Tap a cell to tick it. “All” ticks every period of that credit, and it turns into “None” so you can undo it.
- The footer counts the periods you have ticked and totals their value, so you can see the effect before you save.
- When the sheet opens right after you add a card, “Start from zero” skips it, which is the right choice if you really did use nothing.
The sheet leaves out the period that is running now. You tick that on the card as usual, because you may not have used it yet. It also has nothing to show for yearly credits, which have no closed period inside the year. If you used a yearly credit already, tick its circle on the card.
You can open the same sheet later. Open the card in My Cards and choose “Catch up on earlier periods” (“Tick the periods you already used this year.”). Each monthly, quarterly and twice-a-year credit also shows a count such as “6 of 10 used this year” with minus and plus buttons, handy for a quick fix.

Step 2: find what you actually used
The honest answer comes from your statements, not your memory. Use your issuer’s app or website. Chase, for example, says statements are usually available online for 5 or more years (as of October 2026). Other issuers set their own limits, so check how far back yours go.
Then work through each credit.
- Search for the credit. Credits usually appear as negative amounts or lines marked as credits, often with the programme or partner name. Wording differs by issuer, so search for the partner as well as the word “credit”.
- Look for the purchase and the credit. A credit that arrived in August may belong to a June purchase. Amex’s terms for the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant dining credit say it can take 8 to 12 weeks to post after an eligible charge (as of October 2026).
- Use one rule for the period. If the issuer shows which period a credit counts toward, follow it. If it does not, count the credit in the month of the purchase, and apply that rule to every credit.
- Check the issuer’s own tracker if there is one. Some issuers show benefit usage in your account. Chase’s page for the Sapphire Reserve travel credit, for example, says you can follow your usage by logging in and viewing your card benefits.
The sheet ticks whole periods. If you used only part of a closed month’s credit, you have to choose. Tick it if you used most of it and leave it if you used a small slice. The error either way is small next to the fee.
Card year or calendar year
Not every credit resets in January. Many follow your calendar year. Others follow your card anniversary, the month you opened the card, and that changes the count.
The same issuer can mix both. Chase says (as of October 2026) that its Sapphire Reserve annual travel credit renews on your account anniversary, while The Edit and select Chase Travel hotel credits reset each calendar year. Amex’s terms for the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant describe a dining credit with a cap per calendar year, and a free night award that arrives after renewal and expires one year from issuance. The catalogue entry for the Chase Sapphire Reserve lists both kinds of credit.
For anniversary credits, ValueStack needs the month you opened the card. Open the card, choose Edit card, and fill in “Opened (optional)” with the month and year. It does two things: it shows when the annual fee renews, and it resets anniversary benefits such as free nights and companion vouchers on your card year instead of in January. Until it is set, those benefits count from January. Tap the month again to clear it.
Not sure which kind a credit is? A card’s page, such as the Amex Platinum Card, lists each credit and its cadence, and your issuer’s terms settle it.
Getting an honest year-to-date figure
A few rules keep the number trustworthy.
- Count only what you received. A credit you planned to use but did not is unused. Plans are not captures.
- When in doubt, leave it unticked. The figure becomes a floor. A floor that rises as you find more is easier to trust than a ceiling you have to talk down.
- Know what counts. ValueStack weighs the fee against credits you have ticked, benefits you have redeemed that carry a cash value, and spend goals you have reached. A benefit such as lounge access with no value is reference only. The “Other yearly value” estimate on a card never counts toward break-even.
- Set what you actually paid. If your first-year fee was waived or reduced, open the card, tap “Fee this year” and choose Waived or Another amount, because the app otherwise assumes the listed fee. In India, Mexico and the UAE you enter it before tax, and the app adds the tax. First-year fees and welcome offers goes into this.
- Cross-check the total. Add up the credits you ticked and compare with the “Collected this year” or “Fees earned back” figure. If they disagree, one of the two is wrong, and it is usually a tick.
Once the earlier periods are in, the rest is a habit. A monthly routine to catch credits before they reset shows how to keep it that way, and Tracking your cards in ValueStack covers the screens used here. To judge whether a fee is worth paying, see Is your annual fee worth it?.
Sources used for this guide: Chase on the Sapphire Reserve travel credit and Amex terms for the Marriott Bonvoy Brilliant card.
Fees, credits and posting times are set by your issuer and change. The figures here are examples for personal tracking, not financial advice. Check your issuer’s current terms.
General information for personal tracking, not financial advice. Card terms change often; check the issuer’s current terms.