This guide describes how to review a card and what each option does in general. It does not tell you what to do with any particular card. The details depend on your issuer, your country and your agreement, so check your own terms before acting.
Put a date on the review
Find the date the fee will be billed, usually on your card anniversary, and set two reminders: one about thirty days before, and one for the day after the fee posts, since many refund windows run from that day. Open the card's page, such as the Platinum Card from American Express, the American Express Gold Card or the Chase Sapphire Preferred, to see its credits and when they reset.
In ValueStack, the Overview shows your net so far this year, which is the credits you have checked off minus the fees. The Use it or lose it list shows every unused credit, soonest reset first. Together they answer the first two questions of a review: what has this card paid back, and what is still unclaimed.
Do the arithmetic honestly
You need three numbers: the fee, the credits you actually used, and the benefits you would have paid for anyway, such as a lounge visit you would otherwise have bought. Leave out anything you would not have paid for. Then forecast the next twelve months rather than assuming they will match the last twelve. Credits get renamed, capped or removed, and your habits change. The annual fee guide goes through this in more detail.
What each option does
Keep the card
You pay the fee knowingly and review again next year. It is a decision, not a default, so make it after the arithmetic rather than because the fee is already on the statement.
Ask for a retention offer
A retention offer is an incentive an issuer may give you to keep an account open. Common forms are a statement credit, bonus points that may need some spending, or a reduced or waived fee. Nothing guarantees one: offers vary between cardholders, and some people are offered nothing. People usually ask by phone, either shortly before the fee posts or shortly after.
Judge an offer with the same arithmetic. A credit offsets one year's fee, not the next. An offer that needs spending you would not otherwise do is not free, and a bonus that expires does not change what the card is worth in later years.
Change the product (downgrade)
A product change moves your account to another card from the same issuer. It generally keeps the account and its history, and you receive a new card. Things to check before asking:
- Whether a lower-fee card exists in the issuer's range, since not every card has a path.
- Whether the issuer expects the account to have been open for a minimum period. Some are reported to ask for twelve months, but there is no universal rule, so ask.
- That a product change usually does not earn a welcome offer on the new card.
- What happens to your points, and which credits and benefits you lose.
Cancel the card
Cancelling stops the fee and ends the credits, benefits and protections. The credit-history effect is usually the question people ask, and the general answer has three parts.
- Utilisation. Your total available credit falls, so the share you use rises. The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says this can lower a score and that the change may be temporary or minor, depending on the rest of your profile.
- Account age. Experian says a closed account in good standing can stay on a US credit report for up to ten years, so the history does not vanish when you close the card, but the credit limit does. Rules differ by country.
- Timing. If you plan to apply for a mortgage or loan soon, ask yourself whether a temporary dip matters, and consider paying down balances first.
Experian UK gives a simple illustration. With a £1,000 limit and £250 owed, utilisation is 25%. If cancelling a card cuts the limit to £500 while you still owe £250, it becomes 50%.
Check the refund window
Many issuers refund a fee if you cancel or downgrade within a window after it posts. As of September 2026, a One Mile at a Time roundup reports roughly 30 days at American Express and Chase, 37 days at Citi and 60 days at Barclays, with no consistent policy at Bank of America. It also notes that at American Express a downgrade can attract a prorated refund where a cancellation does not. These are reported practices from a travel site, not contract terms, and they are US figures. Windows elsewhere differ.
Read your cardholder agreement, count from the day the fee was billed, and ask the issuer to confirm the deadline in writing or in a secure message if you are close to it.
Points, miles and vouchers
Rewards earned in a bank's own programme are usually forfeited when you close the card, unless you move them first. Some programmes let you combine points with another card in the same programme, some allow a short window to redeem, and some forfeit at once. Points or miles already in an airline or hotel loyalty account are separate from the card account and generally unaffected, although some programmes expire them after a period of inactivity.
Free nights, companion vouchers and credits can also disappear when a card closes. Use them first or check how the issuer treats them. The use it or lose it guide explains why reset dates matter here.
Redeem or move points before you call to close. A representative may close the account on the call, and transfers are not always instant.
Use what is left, within reason
- Open the Use it or lose it list and note the credits expiring before the fee date.
- Use only what you would genuinely spend anyway. A $15 credit does not justify a $40 purchase.
- If your credits follow the calendar year, remember that a fresh set may arrive in January. That belongs in your forecast.
- If the card is still in its first year, the first-year fees and welcome offers guide explains why year one and year two should be counted separately.
A review checklist
- Write down the fee date and the refund window.
- Total what the card returned and what is still unclaimed.
- Forecast the next twelve months honestly.
- If you decide to ask for a retention offer, compare any offer using the same arithmetic.
- If you are considering a change or cancellation, check points, vouchers and the credit-history effects first.
- Decide, note the reason in the card's note field, and set the next review date.
For the credit-history basics, see the CFPB's page on closing a credit card. This guide is general information and not financial advice.
General information for personal tracking, not financial advice. Card terms change often; check the issuer’s current terms.